A judge on Friday (April 8) threw out Rick Ross’ 2013 lawsuit against LMFAO over the duo’s use of his phrase “everyday I’m hustlin’” for their “Party Anthem” lyric, “everyday I’m shufflin’.”
Per the Hollywood Reporter:
In her opinion, U.S. District Court judge Kathleen M. Williams says the two years of litigation in this case ended where it should have begun — by asking “was the musical composition ‘Hustlin’’ validly registered with the Copyright Office, and, if so, do Plaintiffs have an ownership interest in the exclusive right to prepare derivative works for the musical composition ‘Hustlin’’?”
Williams’ answer to both questions is “no.”
“Because Plaintiffs do not hold a valid copyright registration and because Plaintiffs have not established either legal or beneficial ownership of the exclusive right to prepare derivative works for ‘Hustlin’,’ Plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment is DENIED and this case is DISMISSED,” she writes.
This decision isn’t shocking, considering Williams previously found the three-word phrase not original enough to be copyrightable for use on merchandise.
In March, Ross was dealt another blow when the U.S. Copyright Office issued a statement that a copyright for “Everyday I’m hustlin’” never should have been issued.
“For reasons that have never been made clear, the musical composition ‘Hustlin’’ is the subject of three different registrations with the Copyright Office,” Williams writes. “It should be noted that the second and third registrations were filed by major, global music corporations. Even the most minimal due diligence, through a basic search of the Register’s records (which are easily accessible online), would have revealed these prior registrations.”
Williams says there is undisputed evidence that Ross, and his producers who are also plaintiffs, knew there were competing registrations with inaccuracies and took no steps to fix them.
“Although Plaintiffs have failed to carry their burden of showing proper registration and compliance with the Copyright Act’s statutory formalities, registration does not confer copyright, nor can an erroneous registration take it away,” Williams writes. “However, the failure to properly register a work will preclude an infringement action predicated on that work. And, while the Court’s ruling here does not cancel the registrations, it does bar
Plaintiffs from bringing an infringement action because no valid registration exists.”
Pending Celebrity Lawsuits
1. 50 CentSource:Instagram 1 of 15
2. Chris BrownSource:Instagram 2 of 15
3. A$AP RockySource:Instagram 3 of 15
4. Young MoneySource:Instagram 4 of 15
5. Nicki Minaj, Chris Brown, French Montana, Meek MillSource:AP 5 of 15
6. Kendrick LamarSource:AP 6 of 15
7. Suge KnightSource:AP 7 of 15
8. Rick RossSource:Instagram 8 of 15
9. The GameSource:Instagram 9 of 15
10. Damon Dash and Kanye WestSource:AP 10 of 15
11. DrakeSource:Instagram 11 of 15
12. DJ KahledSource:PR 12 of 15
13. TygaSource:Instagram 13 of 15
14. Snoop DoggSource:AP 14 of 15
15. EminemSource:AP 15 of 15
(Photo Source: PR Photos)