Leave a comment

Who did that Richard Sherman think he was? Justin Bieber?

Making the memes this week is a comparison of Sherman, the Seattle Seahawks cornerback who Twitter racists labeled a thug because of his un-criminal act of boasting about his recent game-saving play, and Bieber, the pop star who Twitter racists have been fairly quiet about since he cursed out the police after they arrested him in Miami for his illegal act of drag racing.

See meme in photo gallery below.

The meme rightly points out the double-standard that black and white celebrities are held to; a Stanford-educated, exceptionally skilled black football player is quickly denigrated as a gang-banger and troublemaker simply for being loud and proud, while a white pop star’s lawbreaking craziness is excused as him being just a mixed-up kid. To them, Sherman’s bragging equals incorrigibility, while Bieber’s antics amount to a cry for help.

To them, the Richard Shermans of the world deserve our condemnation, while the Justin Biebers of the world deserve our empathy.

But to me, the Sherman versus Bieber meme doesn’t just speak to a racial double-standard, but to the suffocating standards that many Americans still expect black men to adhere to no matter how accomplished they are.

Think about it.

All Sherman really did was crow about his victory over his opponent after he had played a brutal, bruising game in which his team wasn’t expected to win. That’s not thuggish behavior – and those who would call it that aren’t really responding to his bragging.

What they’re responding to is him being black and having the nerve to not be quiet and fade into the background after achieving something awesome; to not behave as background noise when he, in fact, brought the noise.

They don’t mind Sherman being black and smart and skilled. They just don’t want Sherman, a black man with dreadlocks and a Stanford degree, to verbally remind them that he’s, well, black and smart and skilled.

That’s a little tough for them to take.

We know this reality exists based on the racist responses to President Obama.

How many times has Obama been referred to as arrogant because he defied expectations and changed the health care system in this country? Or because he tries to find ways to do the job of getting legislation passed in spite of an intransigent Congress?

How many Tea Party racists and their ignorant ilk continue to overlook the fact that Obama is a Harvard-educated, constitutional law professor as they insist on saying he’s violating the Constitution? How many continue to call him a Chicago thug? A dictator-in-waiting?

All because he had the nerve to be black, run for president and win – twice.

So to me, this isn’t just about how some whites eviscerate Sherman while they empathize with Bieber. It’s about how many Americans still expect black men to be humble about their success and white people to be assertive about theirs.

It’s about how many whites expect for black men to not acknowledge their own worthiness unless white people do it first.

It’s been that way at least since the 1960s and 70s, when a bragging Muhammad Ali became the heavyweight champion of the world three times. We see it happening with Obama. Nervy black men have always been viewed as threats.

And what happened with Sherman shows that hasn’t changed much.


Tonyaa Weathersbee is an award-winning columnist based in Jacksonville, Fla. Follow her at @tonyaajw. Like her at http://www.facebook.com/tonyaajweathersbee.

Social Media Responds to Bieber Arrest
6 photos

5 thoughts on “Why is Sherman a ‘Thug’ for Boasting? It All Boils Down to Black and White

  1. the Timekeeper on said:

    Sherman was absolutley correct. Thug has become the new (subtle) term for a racila slur against blacks. It doesnt matter what he majored in at Stanford. At least, He Went! You can always find a Stephen ( as in Django who will tear a brother down as a few are trying to do on this page just ot make himself ( or herself) sound good. It says more about them than it does about Sherman. I have been excited at the end of pickup games, so I can imagine the exhiliration he felt knowing he was going to the Super Bowl. If you’ve never played the game you just wouldnt understand. Although some of you are playing games of another kind. Every man of color who doesnt jiump when America says How High? is then labeled a Thug. How convenient.
    Sherman is a highly intelligent, very talented football player who had the audacity to be in player mode when this no account non football knowedge, so called eye candy named Erin Andrews put that microphone in his face. Oh, the horror! Give me a break. She and (White) America need to get real, As do those who dont know Mr. Sherman and want to talk out of the left side of their mouths.

  2. come on people, there’s no comparison between the two, one’s an idiot, the other one is suppose 2 b a STANFORD GRAD, P/S WHAT DID HE STUDY N SCHOOL, IT SURE WASN’T SPEAKING N PUBLIC.. SCHOOL SHOULD B PROUD OF A STANFORD GRAD. HA!!!

    • Blackmoses73 on said:

      It’s bad enough we have Jiggy5 on here belittling Black people, now we have his whore. Peggy Harris,i’m not saying that just because you are black (using that loosly) you have to praise black people but come on your comment was not cool.You seem to be the kind of black person to talk down on your own race just to get approval at the office.You are sad because at the end of the day you are sill a ?????

  3. Jiggy5 on said:

    Stanford educated? You really gonna go there. Yeah, and Patrick Ewing was Georgetown “educated”.
    Holla’ at the Scholar

  4. VBucGreen on said:

    Blacks in general and particularly Black Men’s have to value themselves and not wait on white America for confirmation. White America expects all Black Men to be uneducated, swaging pants, and drug dealers. They will never accept that our ancestors built this United States of America and now they have no use for us, since the job is complete.

Add Your Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s