CLOSE

1. Joe

Our vote: better

2. K. Michelle

Our vote: worse

3. Ray J

Our vote: worse

4. Solange

5. Jill Scott

Our vote: better

6. Nicki Minaj

Our vote: better

7. Jennifer Hudson

Our vote: better

8. Jodeici

Our vote: worse

9. Tamar Braxton

Our vote: better

10. Kelly Rowland

Our vote: better

11. Aretha Franklin

Our vote: worse (will all due respect to the Queen)

12. Keke Wyatt

Our vote: better

13. Alicia Keys

Our vote: worse

14. Monica

Our vote: better

15. Rihanna

Our vote: better

16. Beyonce

Our vote: better