A 21-year-old woman who hosted a gender reveal party where nine people were shot, was never pregnant at all, police say. The Cincinatti, Ohio supposed mother-to-be was wounded when two men burst into her home and shot up the party earlier this month. The suspects have not been caught and police are saying that had the truth been told from the beginning they might not have wasted time tracking down false leads.
Cheyanne Willis, 21, was one of the nine people shot at her party on July 8 when two people opened fire on the group as they watched a movie. One attendee, Autumn Garrett, 21, died, while Willis was shot in the leg.
Now, Colerain Township police say Willis was never pregnant, despite her family’s claims.
Police spokesman James Love tells PEOPLE authorities are frustrated by the apparent lie but continue to try to solve the shooting.
“As ridiculous as it might be, it’s not a crime to lie, it’s not a crime to have a party over that lie,” says Love. “Now if she lied and put everyone in the danger — of course the shooters would be the main focus but [to press charges] would be a decision up to the local prosecutors.”
Speaking with PEOPLE on Friday, before the police announcement, Willis’ sister Amber White said Willis was “excited” to be a mother.
“She had a miscarriage right before and she’s been wanting a child,” White, a mother herself, said. “She’s a great aunt.”
White attended the party but left before the shooting began, she said. When asked how Willis was doing after ostensibly losing her baby, White said she was “devastated.”
During the party, Willis posted photos on her social media with attendees announcing that her baby would be a boy.