LAS VEGAS (AP) — Imprisoned former football star O.J. Simpson lost his latest appeal of his 2008 kidnapping and armed robbery conviction in Las Vegas.
A three-member Nevada Supreme Court panel rejected Simpson’s request for a new trial, ruling in a 16-page order Thursday that there was no reason to overturn a lower court judge’s decisions in the case.
“We … conclude the district court did not err in denying these claims,” justices Ron Parraguire, Michael Douglas and Michael Cherry said.
Simpson lawyers filed the appeal last October, arguing that Clark County District Court Judge Linda Marie Bell was wrong to deny Simpson a new trial on charges that got Simpson sentenced to 9 to 33 years in a botched hotel room heist.
Simpson lawyers Patricia Palm, Ozzie Fumo and Tom Pitaro argued that his trial attorney mishandled his case and had conflicts of interests. The three attorneys didn’t immediately respond to messages late Thursday, and it wasn’t immediately known if Simpson was aware of the ruling.
Simpson, 68, is serving his sentence in a northern Nevada prison after a jury found him guilty of multiple felonies for leading five other men in a September 2007 confrontation with two sports memorabilia dealers at a Las Vegas hotel. Two of the men with Simpson testified they brought guns, at Simpson’s request.
The Heisman Trophy winner, NFL Hall of Fame member and former television and movie star didn’t testify at his robbery trial in Las Vegas. His attorneys, Yale Galanter and Gabriel Grasso, claimed Simpson was just trying to retrieve items stolen from him after his 1995 acquittal in Los Angeles in the deaths of his ex-wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and her friend, Ronald Goldman.
The Supreme Court in September 2010 rejected a previous Simpson appeal, filed by Galanter.
Simpson’s appeal argued that his multiple convictions and sentences for assault with a deadly weapon and robbery with use of a deadly weapon constitute double-jeopardy; that Galanter should have challenged his multiple convictions and punishments; and that the jury should have been given a chance to consider lesser kidnapping and theft offenses.
Galanter denied the allegations that he mishandled Simpson’s case and had conflicted interests.
Bell held several days of hearings in May 2013 on Simpson’s claims. Simpson testified, and continued to insist he never knew any of the men with him were carrying guns.
Bell ruled in November 2013 that any errors at trial wouldn’t have changed the outcome of Simpson’s trial, and agreed with prosecutors that there was no need for another trial.
The judge said she reviewed the entire court record and determined there was overwhelming evidence that Simpson orchestrated the armed kidnapping and robbery.
Four men who were with Simpson pleaded guilty before trial to felonies and served probation.
One co-defendant, Clarence “C.J.” Stewart, stood trial with Simpson and was convicted.
Stewart was sentenced to 7½ to 27 years, but his conviction was overturned by the Supreme Court as tainted by Simpson’s fame. Stewart avoided retrial, pleaded guilty to felony robbery and conspiracy, was freed from prison after serving more than two years.
Professional Sports Hall of Shame
1. Ray McDonaldSource:AP 1 of 26
2. Warren Sapp2 of 26
3. Josh GordonSource:AP 3 of 26
4. Josh BrentSource:AP 4 of 26
5. Dimitri PattersonSource:AP 5 of 26
6. Floyd MayweatherSource:Instagram 6 of 26
7. Darren SharperSource:AP 7 of 26
8. Ray RiceSource:AP 8 of 26
9. O.J. Simpson9 of 26
10. Raw Carruth10 of 26
11. Plaxico Burress11 of 26
12. Dwayne Goodrich12 of 26
13. Aaron Hernandez13 of 26
14. Michael Vick14 of 26
15. Terry 'Tank' Johnson15 of 26
16. Donte Stallworth16 of 26
17. Darryl Henly17 of 26
18. Pete Rose18 of 26
19. Darryl Strawberry19 of 26
20. Jayson Williams20 of 26
21. Tom Payne21 of 26
22. Mike Tyson22 of 26
23. Tonya Harding23 of 26
24. Marion Jones24 of 26
25. Mike Danton25 of 26
26. Chad Johnson26 of 26
(Photo Source: AP)