Including destination charges, the 2014 Cruze starts out the gate at $25,695, while the 2103 Jetta TDI starts out the gate slightly lower, with a starting price of $24,885, when equipped with an automatic (and $23,785 when equipped with the manual transmission). Both vehicles offer a 2.0-liter clean diesel engine. And, both vehicles have the same light clatter ticking from the engine buyers have become accustomed to with diesels. Unlike the Cruze, which produces 148-horsepower, with 258 lb.-ft. torque, the Jetta only pushes out 140-hosepower, with 236 lb. –ft. torque. In comparing the two, there is a little lag in the VW at start, but once the Jetta warms up, there is no turning back.
According to fueleconomy.gov, the Cruze and the Jetta has a fuel tank range of 463 and 444 miles per gallon, respectively. The Cruze has a combined fuel economy of 33 miles per gallons, garnering 27 miles per gallon in the city and 46 miles per gallon on the highway. Conversely, the Jetta achieves a combined fuel economy of 34 miles per gallon. In the city, the Jetta achieves 30 miles per gallon in the city and 42 miles per gallon on the highway.
Inside of the Cruze, consumers will find a more aesthetically appealing interior, which gives the illusion of the vehicle being a premium priced vehicle. Although as noted, the Cruze is priced slightly higher than the VW, there are a number of features that separate the two compacts. For example, the Cruze is equipped with such standard features as 17-inch wheels, an automatic transmission, 10-standard air bags, leather seats, a power driver seat, the brand’s smartphone-like MyLink system, a 5-year/100,000 mile powertrain warranty, a 2-year/24,000-mile free maintenance warranty and GM’s OnStar system, which provide directions and concierge-type services. Moreover, for an additional price, Cruze buyers can opt for a review back-up camera, a rear-traffic cross alert system, and radar-activated blind-spot side mirrors. None of the noted features are available in the VW.
On the other hand, at the price noted above, the VW is outfitted with standard 16-inch wheels, 5 airbags, leather-like seats, the option of a manual transmission engine and a 3-year/36,000-mile free maintenance plan.
Pricing And Mileage
Outside of the diesel segment, Chevy offers a Cruze Eco model in either a manual or an automatic configuration that costs about $4,000 to $5,000 less, which achieves 26 miles per gallon in the city and 39 miles per gallon on the highway. VW offers a gasoline model, too, with comparable mileage to combat the pricing issue. Furthermore, VW offers a Jetta hybrid, which costs about the same as the Cruze diesel. The Jetta hybrid garners 48 miles per gallon on the highway, which is only 2 miles per gallon more than the well-contented Cruze diesel. Nevertheless, serious diesel buyers are willing to pay the premium, just as hybrid buyers. On the flip side, Chevy could offer a de-contented diesel, lowering the price to capture price-sensitive buyers.
While the Cruze diesel is overall a better value as it relates to content, when compared to the segment leader, the Jetta TDI. Until now, American diesel car buyers haven’t had an option. While the Jetta TDI has had success both here and abroad, the Chevy diesel has only in Europe. GM is counting on consumers to look to the success they have had with diesels in their non-American brand, Opel. Moreover, consumers can’t forget the fact that GM has also been successful in building reliable diesels in their light duty and medium duty segments, too. And, at 46 miles per gallon, the executives at GM are counting on well-informed consumers to drive sales. Added to that, Chevy executives are also hoping to drive home the point that the Cruze diesel offers better highway mileage than any other non-hybrid passenger car in America.
About the Writer
Jeff Fortson is an auto analyst and editor of a car-buying website for women and minorities. To learn more about his popular car-buying workshop and/or to price a new-vehicle, drive on over to JeffCars.com. Follow him http://twitter.com/#!/JeffCars/.